Home l About Fay's | About Eveyln Bay | Directions (517) 543-9770 Contact Us

134 S. Cochran St. Charlotte, Michigan
Fays Evelyn Bay Coffee Company, Great Deals, Great Fun!


Fays Evelyn Bay

View Coffee Menu

Cold Drinks

Canned Beverages
Italian Soda - soda water, flavored syrup
Bottled Water
Flavored Iced Tea - Blueberry, Raspberry, or Pomegranate
Coca-Cola - Vanilla or Cherry

Classic Espresso Drinks (Hot or Iced)

Available with decaf, skim milk.
Half & Half, Soy milk or extra shot espresso is additional $.50

Café Mocha - espresso shot, Chocolate syrup, steamed milk, whipped cream
Café Latte - espresso shot, steamed milk
Cappuccino - espresso shot, steamed milk, foam

Café Americano - espresso shot, hot water

Other Hot Drinks

Shot of Espresso
House Coffee
Hot Chocolate
Chai Latte - spiced tea, honey,milk, whipped cream
Hot tea - Tazo Choose assorted tea bags


Breakfast Sandwich - Choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage Prepared with egg and cheese. Served on Toast, Biscuit, Bagel or English Muffin
Sausage Gravy & Biscuits

Assorted Muffins
Bagel with butter or cream cheese
Cookie - Daily Assortment

Fays Evelyn Bay

Choose Two

Signature Selection - Choice of two: Bowl of soup, half salad, half Signature Panini
Café Selection - Choice of Cup of soup & half Café Sandwich


Our soups get rave reviews. Call us for the soup of the day.

Signature Paninis

SouthWest Chicken Panini - Southwestern sauce, fajita chicken strips, cheddar cheese and red onion
Chipolte Turkey Panini - Sliced Turkey, chipolte sauce, cheddar cheese and red onion
Ham Panini - Shaved ham, spicy brown mustard and mayo, lettuce, Swiss cheese
Grilled Cheese Panini
Corned Beef Reuben - Corned beef, swiss cheese,1000 island drsg.,


(choose Tomato Basil, White or Whole Wheat wrap)
Turkey Bacon - roasted turkey, bacon, cheddar cheese, red onion, leaf lettuce, tomato, seasoned mayo
- Sliced ham, cheddar cheese, red onion, lettuce, honey mustard spread
Veggie Wrap
- Choice of veggies, lettuce, tomato, onion, cukes, shredded carrot, and choice of dressing

Fays Evelyn Bay

View Ice Cream Menu


- choose Ranch, French, Bleu cheese, Caesar, Raspberry
vineagrette, 1000 island, Poppy seed, FF Ranch, or Italian drsg.

Turkey Waldorf - Romaine blend, turkey, sliced apples, dried cranberries, red onion, chopped pecans & Raspberry vineagrette
Chef Salad - Iceberg lettuce, ham, turkey, cheddar and swiss cheese, carrots, cucumbers, eggs, tomatoes & choice of dressing
Orange Chicken Salad- Romaine blend, seasoned chicken, mandarin oranges, grapes, & Poppy seed dressing
Garden Salad - Romaine blend, tomatoes, red onion,

Café Sandwiches

- choose Wheatberry, Sour dough or Wheat bread

Turkey - Roast turkey breast, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayo, tomato
Ham - sliced ham, swiss cheese, lettuce, mayo and tomato
Chicken Salad - (pecans, craisins, celery, grapes, mayo) and lettuce
Tuna Salad - Premium Albacore Tuna
Egg Salad - Homemade